Blue-eyed Child of Fortune

Brief Summary

Blue-eyed Child of Fortune by Russell Duncan is a compelling compilation of nearly two hundred letters written by Colonel Robert Gould Shaw, the Civil War hero portrayed in the film Glory. These letters provide a profound insight into Shaw's personal journey and transformation. Initially hesitant to command the North's first black regiment, Shaw's correspondence reveals how his reservations gave way to a deep sense of loyalty and dedication. Through the intimate lens of personal letters, readers are offered a glimpse into the complexities and challenges faced by Shaw during a pivotal moment in American history.

Main Themes and Topics

The book primarily explores themes of duty, leadership, and racial integration during the American Civil War. It delves into the struggles and moral dilemmas faced by Shaw as he navigates his role in a racially segregated military environment. The transformation of Shaw's perspective on race and command underlines the evolving attitudes towards racial equality during this era. Additionally, the book addresses themes of bravery, honor, and the power of personal conviction in the face of societal and military challenges.

Writing Style and Tone

Russell Duncan provides a meticulously researched and eloquent narrative that complements Shaw's letters. The tone of the book is reflective and enlightening, offering readers a historical lens that is both detailed and personal. Duncan's editorial work brings clarity and context to Shaw's thoughts, allowing readers to fully appreciate the impact of his experiences. The writing style is engaging and accessible, drawing readers into the emotional and intellectual world of Colonel Shaw.

Criticism

While Blue-eyed Child of Fortune has been praised for offering an intimate look at Shaw's inner thoughts, some critics note that the book may lean heavily on the letters without providing enough interpretive analysis from the author. The reliance on primary source material, while valuable, might leave some readers wanting more comprehensive historical context or interpretation to fully understand the broader implications of Shaw's experiences beyond the personal realm.