British and Commonwealth Merchant Ship Losses to Axis Submarines, 1939-1945

Main Themes and Topics

British and Commonwealth Merchant Ship Losses to Axis Submarines, 1939-1945 by Alan J. Tennent is an authoritative reference work that delves into the significant maritime conflicts between British and Commonwealth merchant vessels and Axis submarines during the Second World War. The book meticulously documents the details of each ship's sinking, providing insights into the broader strategic impact of submarine warfare on merchant shipping. Tennent examines the role of German U-boats, detailing each engagement's timeline, the U-boat commanders involved, and the fate of both ships and their crews. Additionally, the book discusses Operation 'Deadlight,' the post-war operation conducted by the Royal Navy to dispose of captured German submarines.

Writing Style and Tone

Tennent's writing style is precise and fact-focused, characteristic of a comprehensive reference volume. The tone is analytical and devoid of unnecessary dramatization, which suits the book's aim to serve as a reference for maritime historians and enthusiasts. Each entry is methodically structured to present factual information without editorial commentary, making the book accessible for those seeking data-driven insights into the era's naval engagements.

Criticism

Some readers may find Tennent's detailed account to be overly dense, as the book prioritizes exhaustive data compilation over narrative storytelling. This format, while beneficial for research purposes, may not engage casual readers or those looking for a more flowing narrative about World War II maritime history. Additionally, the focus on British and Commonwealth perspectives might limit the scope for readers interested in a more balanced account that includes Axis narratives.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

This book is a comprehensive survey of the losses incurred by British and Commonwealth merchant ships due to Axis submarine attacks between 1939 and 1945. Through meticulous research and a wealth of primary sources, Tennent offers an in-depth look at the strategic role of merchant shipping during World War II and the threat posed to it by Axis U-boats. The book also covers the subsequent disposal operations of Axis submarines by the Royal Navy, providing a complete picture of this aspect of maritime warfare.