"Execute Against Japan"

Main Themes and Topics

"Execute Against Japan" by Joel Ira Holwitt explores the controversial transition of the United States Navy from adhering to naval arms treaties to implementing a policy of unrestricted submarine warfare against Japan following the attack on Pearl Harbor. The book delves into the complex interaction of history, policy, and international law, meticulously dissecting the decisions and events that led to this dramatic shift. Holwitt's work provides a thorough analysis of the origins of unrestricted warfare and its vital role in the Pacific War, offering readers a comprehensive understanding of a pivotal moment in naval history.

Writing Style and Tone

Holwitt's writing is detailed and well-researched, characterized by its analytical and investigative approach. He presents a compelling narrative that remains accessible to both scholars and general readers interested in military history. His style balances technical precision with an engaging narrative, ensuring that complex legal and military concepts are communicated clearly. Moreover, his willingness to address the moral implications of the United States' strategic decisions adds depth to his analysis, encouraging readers to reflect on the broader ethical dimensions of warfare.

Awards and Recognition

"Execute Against Japan" has been recognized for its scholarly contribution to naval history. It has been recommended as essential reading for naval officers, particularly those serving in submarines, at the US Naval War College. The book has also received praise from notable publications, such as World War II Magazine and Military Review, for its exhaustive examination of the subject and Holwitt's courage in tackling moral considerations within military strategy.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

The book uncovers the story behind the United States' decision to engage in unrestricted submarine warfare against Japan, scrutinizing the period's legal and ethical challenges. Through a detailed account of the key figures and decisions involved, Holwitt illustrates how historical, policy, and legal frameworks were navigated to implement a strategy deemed critical to the U.S. Navy's success in the Pacific theater during World War II.