For Slavery and Union

Main Themes and Topics

For Slavery and Union by Patrick A. Lewis serves as a detailed exploration of Kentucky's conservative proslavery Unionists during the Civil War and Reconstruction eras. The book delves into the complex identity of Benjamin Forsythe Buckner, a Kentucky aristocrat who defied his family and peers by joining the Union cause. Through Buckner's experiences, Lewis examines the broader themes of loyalty, societal change, and the intersection of economic growth and racial control. The book provides insights into the political and social dynamics of Kentucky, highlighting the role of proslavery forces in shaping the post-war South.

Writing Style and Tone

Patrick A. Lewis employs a scholarly and engaging writing style to narrate the intricate details of Benjamin Buckner's life and the period's historical context. The tone is analytical yet accessible, making it suitable for both academic and general readers with an interest in Civil War history. Lewis effectively balances between biographical storytelling and historical analysis, providing a nuanced perspective that captivates without overwhelming the reader with excessive detail.

Criticism

While For Slavery and Union is widely praised for its detailed research and insightful analysis, some readers might find the book's focus on a singular figure, Benjamin Buckner, as a potential limitation. The emphasis on Buckner's personal journey might not fully satisfy those seeking a broader overview of Kentucky's political and social landscape during the Civil War. However, this biographical approach offers an intimate glimpse into the mindsets and motivations of Kentucky’s conservative proslavery Unionists.

Brief Summary

For Slavery and Union traces the story of Benjamin Forsythe Buckner, a Kentucky aristocrat whose loyalties were torn as the Civil War unfolded. Despite his allegiance to the Union, Buckner's proslavery stance reveals the complexities faced by individuals in border states like Kentucky. Through Buckner's life, Patrick A. Lewis offers a window into the larger historical transformations occurring during the Reconstruction era, particularly the collaboration between conservative and proslavery forces in the transition toward the New South.