General George E. Pickett in Life and Legend

Main Themes and Topics

General George E. Pickett in Life and Legend by Lesley J. Gordon delves deeply into the life and myth surrounding one of the most recognized figures from the Confederate side of the American Civil War. Gordon's biography brings a nuanced perspective by intertwining Pickett's military exploits with the pivotal role his wife, LaSalle Corbell Pickett, played in shaping his posthumous reputation. The central theme is the contrast between Pickett's historical persona, as influenced by his wife's dedicated efforts, and his actual life experiences and military record.

The book meticulously details Pickett's early life and career, providing insights into his formative years at West Point, his service in the Mexican-American War, and his frontier postings. As the narrative progresses, Gordon examines Pickett's participation in the Civil War, with particular emphasis on the renowned yet ill-fated charge at Gettysburg—a moment that thrust him into the spotlight with a rather mixed legacy regarding military prowess.

Writing Style and Tone

Lesley J. Gordon's writing style in this biography is both analytical and engaging, combining rigorous historical research with an accessible narrative. The tone is scholarly yet appealing to a general audience interested in Civil War history. By providing deep context and a critical examination of primary sources, Gordon manages to dissect the layers of myth and fact that have clouded Pickett's story over the years. Her ability to craft a coherent story from fragmented historical records is particularly noteworthy.

Criticism

While General George E. Pickett in Life and Legend is widely praised for its thorough research and balanced perspective, some critics have pointed to the challenging task of disentangling fact from fiction in the narrative, due to the heavy mythologizing that surrounded Pickett's life, particularly by his wife LaSalle. The book's reliance on existing documentation, much of which was influenced by LaSalle's writings, sometimes makes it difficult to fully separate the real Pickett from the legend. However, these challenges are inherent in the topic itself, and Gordon is generally commended for her rigorous approach in handling these issues.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

This biography of General George E. Pickett provides a comprehensive look at both the man and the myth that surrounds him. Starting from his early life, Gordon follows Pickett’s journey through his military career leading up to and during the Civil War, highlighting key moments such as Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg. A significant portion of the book is dedicated to exploring the influence of LaSalle Corbell Pickett, whose extensive efforts to control her husband's legacy played a crucial role in shaping public perception. The result is a multifaceted exploration of both biography and historiography, shedding light on how historical narratives are constructed and maintained over time.