Inventing Custer

Brief Summary

"Inventing Custer: The Making of an American Legend" by Edward Caudill delves into how Custer's defeat at the Battle of Little Bighorn transcended from a momentary historical event into an enduring legend. Caudill, with co-author Paul Ashdown, examines the transformation of George Armstrong Custer into a mythic figure, contrasting the historical character with his literary and cultural representation. The book explores the influences that shaped Custer's image, from the press to shifting perceptions of American Indians, highlighting the evolution of his myth alongside America's cultural progression.

Main Themes and Topics

The book prominently tackles themes of mythmaking and the construction of legends from historical events. It delves into how societal and cultural changes influence public memory and interpretation, using Custer as a focal point. Caudill and Ashdown also explore the role of media in shaping historical narratives and the interplay between historical truths and mythologized retellings.

Writing Style and Tone

Caudill's writing style in "Inventing Custer" is analytical yet accessible, making complex historical analysis engaging to a broad audience. The tone is objective, with a focus on dissecting cultural and historical narratives without romanticizing Custer or his time. The authors employ comprehensive research and present their findings with clarity, often drawing connections between past and present cultural sentiments.

Criticism

Some readers and critics might argue that the book's academic approach could be dense for those without a strong interest in American history or media studies. Additionally, the focus on the mythmaking process might overshadow a detailed military analysis of Custer's strategies and actions during the battles he engaged in, which could disappoint readers seeking a more military-focused historical account.