Isham G. Harris of Tennessee

Brief Summary

"Isham G. Harris of Tennessee" by Sam Davis Elliott presents a detailed account of the political career of Isham Green Harris, an influential figure in Tennessee's history. Starting as a leader of the southern rights wing of the Democratic Party in the 1850s, Harris leveraged his position as governor during the secession crisis of 1861 to align Tennessee with the Confederacy. His tenure included controversial decisions that often placed him at odds with constitutional norms. After the Confederacy's defeat, Harris went into a temporary exile in Mexico before returning to the United States. In 1877, he was elected as a United States Senator, where he served until his death, becoming a prominent figure among Tennessee's Bourbon Democrats.

Main Themes and Topics

The book intricately explores themes of political power, loyalty, and legal ambiguity. It delves into Harris's unwavering support for the Confederate cause and his actions that stretched, and sometimes broke, constitutional boundaries. Elliott examines Harris's role in the larger context of Tennessee and Southern politics in the 19th century, providing insight into the complexities of governance during wartime. The narrative also highlights Harris's post-war political rehabilitation and his influence in the Bourbon Democrat movement, which sought to restore conservative values and Southern influence in American politics after Reconstruction.

Writing Style and Tone

Sam Davis Elliott employs a scholarly yet accessible writing style that caters to both historians and general readers interested in American Civil War history. The tone is balanced and factual, presenting Harris's controversial actions and their implications with objectivity. Elliott's meticulous research is evident in the detailed accounts and the robust analysis of political strategies and their consequences. The prose is engaging, maintaining a steady pace that guides readers through complex historical events and political maneuvers.

Criticism

While the book is praised for its thorough research and detailed narrative, some readers may find the dense political analysis challenging to navigate. The emphasis on political intricacies could overshadow personal insights into Harris's character, which might leave those seeking a more intimate biography wanting. Nonetheless, Elliott's dedication to historical accuracy and comprehensive coverage is generally well-received among academics and history enthusiasts.