Lost Patrols

Main Themes and Topics

In "Lost Patrols," Innes McCartney immerses readers into the haunting yet fascinating historical account of submarines lying at the bottom of the English Channel. A poignant exploration of maritime history, the book delves into the stories of 121 submarines that met their fates due to war and peacetime accidents. Stretching from the loss of the first submarine in 1774 to the tragic accident of the HMS Affray in 1951, McCartney paints a vivid picture of the progression of submarine technology and the perilous conditions faced by their crews. The book is a meditative reflection on the convergence of human ingenuity and its vulnerability to nature's vast oceanic domain.

Writing Style and Tone

Innes McCartney's writing in "Lost Patrols" is both meticulously detailed and evocatively descriptive. His narrative offers a delicate balance between being informative and engaging, which is no small feat given the extensive historical breadth covered. McCartney has a knack for humanizing these mechanical behemoths of the sea, imbuing each sunken submarine with a vivid story that reflects the broader tapestry of maritime history. His tone is reverent and somber, appropriately honoring the memory of the vessels and their crews, while also inviting readers to ponder the enormity of their sacrifice and the historical significance of their loss.

Criticism

While "Lost Patrols" is comprehensive in its coverage and rich in detail, some readers may find the sheer volume of information overwhelming. In certain sections, the book reads more like an exhaustive historical catalog than a narrative-driven account, which may deter readers unfamiliar with naval military history. However, for those with a keen interest in the subject, this level of detail can be seen as an asset. Additionally, the technical jargon associated with submarine operations and maritime warfare might pose a challenge to lay readers, potentially limiting the book's accessibility to a wider audience.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

"Lost Patrols" embarks on a journey through time, enlivening the silent stories of 121 submarines that rest beneath the waves of the English Channel. From the inception of the submarine era in the late 18th century to the mid-20th century, McCartney provides a somber yet enthralling tapestry of maritime technology, military encounters, and human endeavor. Each chapter unveils distinct episodes of history, stringing together not just the lifespans of the submarines themselves, but also the broader implications of their losses at sea. Through these underwater graveyards, the book resonates as a tribute to the bravery and ingenuity of those who ventured into the depths.