Mother of the Company

Brief Summary

Mother of the Company by Philip M. Smith is a poignant exploration of the experiences of Sgt. Percy M. Smith, a World War II soldier. Through his letters and memories as an aging veteran, the book sheds light on the complexities of military life, the impact of war, and the emotional dynamics that shaped his perceptions of himself and others. It captures the journey of a common enlisted man from embarkation to discharge and offers insight into his personal relationships and the evolving judgments of fellow soldiers, military leadership, and the home front.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves into the themes of military camaraderie and the psychological impact of war on soldiers. It highlights the strengths and vulnerabilities that soldiers like Sgt. Percy Smith experienced during wartime and occupation. The letters serve as a testament to the emotional turmoil and the need for comfort among veterans, while also confronting the prejudices of the era. Through this intimate collection of letters, the narrative suggests a redefinition of what it means to be a 'good soldier,' emphasizing life-giving and nurturing instincts amidst the harsh realities of war.

Writing Style and Tone

Philip M. Smith employs a reflective and empathetic tone throughout the book, allowing the readers to connect with Sgt. Percy Smith on a personal level. The writing is candid and earnest, capturing the authentic voice of a soldier grappling with the duality of duty and the inherent vulnerability of human emotions. The narrative effectively balances historical context with personal reflection, adding depth to the historical events through the lens of personal experience.

Criticism

While Mother of the Company provides a compelling insight into the personal experiences of a World War II soldier, some readers might find the book to lack the broader historical perspective often expected in military memoirs. The focus is largely on the personal narrative, which though rich in emotional detail, may not satisfy those seeking a comprehensive account of the war itself. Additionally, the structure of alternating between letters and reflections might come across as fragmented for readers looking for a more linear storytelling approach.