Not by Omission

Main Themes and Topics

Not by Omission by Amnon Kapeliouk offers a critical examination of the circumstances leading up to the 1973 Arab-Israel war. This book delves into the diplomatic interactions—or lack thereof—between Israel and Egypt following the 1967 conflict. Kapeliouk highlights how diplomatic overtures by Egyptian leaders, Presidents Nasser and Sadat, were dismissed or ignored by Israeli leadership.

Central themes include the hubristic attitudes entrenched within the Israeli military and political establishments, particularly focusing on figures like Golda Meir, Moshe Dayan, and Israel Galili. These leaders are scrutinized for their roles in fostering a sense of complacency that culminated in military and political crises. Furthermore, Kapeliouk examines Israel’s post-war settlement policies in territories like the Golan Heights and the West Bank, portraying these actions as catalysts that provoked further regional tensions.

Writing Style and Tone

Amnon Kapeliouk's writing is analytical and incisive, reflecting his background as a seasoned journalist and commentator. The tone of the book is critical, combining detailed investigative journalism with a clear urgency about the lessons that historical events hold for contemporary politics. Kapeliouk's narrative is supported by ample evidence, making a compelling case for re-evaluating the established narratives of the 1973 war.

Criticism

One area of criticism that readers might find is the book’s complex narrative, which assumes a degree of familiarity with Middle Eastern history and politics. This could make it challenging for readers who are new to the topic to fully grasp all the nuances of Kapeliouk's arguments. However, those with an understanding of the historical backdrop will likely appreciate the depth of analysis provided.

Brief Summary

Not by Omission delivers a thorough critique of Israeli policies and the socio-political landscape leading up to the 1973 Middle East war. It highlights the failures of Israeli leadership to engage adequately with regional diplomacy and addresses the internal dissent that surfaced post-war. By revisiting the decisions made during this period, Kapeliouk illustrates how these events laid the groundwork for ongoing regional conflicts. Introduced by Noam Chomsky, the book situates Kapeliouk's insights in a broader historical context, amplifying its relevance and urgency.