Pickett, Leader of the Charge

Brief Summary

"Pickett, Leader of the Charge" by Edward G. Longacre is a comprehensive biography that delves into the life and legacy of George E. Pickett, famously known for leading Pickett's Charge during the Battle of Gettysburg. The book uncovers the complexities and contradictions in Pickett's character, examining how a man renowned for his bravery on the battlefield simultaneously avoided the carnage of Gettysburg's climactic assault. Longacre draws on both published and unpublished primary sources to offer a nuanced depiction of Pickett, challenging longstanding myths and misconceptions surrounding the general's historical image.

Main Themes and Topics

The biography focuses on several core themes, including the duality of Pickett's nature. It explores the juxtaposition between his gallant persona and his actions during pivotal moments of the Civil War. Longacre introduces readers to Pickett as a layered individual whose professional and personal choices were often inconsistent. Another significant theme is the deconstruction of myths that have surrounded Pickett over the years. The author addresses the inaccuracies in previous narratives, notably discrediting collections of letters that were falsely attributed to Pickett, highlighting the influence of his widow in shaping his posthumous reputation.

Writing Style and Tone

Edward G. Longacre employs a scholarly yet accessible tone in "Pickett, Leader of the Charge." His writing is meticulous, characterized by detailed research and careful analysis. Longacre's style is informative, maintaining a balance between academic rigor and engaging storytelling. The book's tone reflects a commitment to historical accuracy and reveals Longacre's passion for debunking historical myths while providing an enlightening view of George E. Pickett's life.

Criticism

While Longacre's work is commendable for its thorough approach and myth-busting revelations, some readers may find the extensive focus on primary sources dense and challenging to navigate. The detailed analysis, though essential for understanding Pickett in depth, might overwhelm readers seeking a more succinct narrative. Nevertheless, this level of detail is appreciated by those interested in an exhaustive study of Civil War history.