Resolute Rebel

Brief Summary

Resolute Rebel by Chet Bennett is the first comprehensive biography of Roswell S. Ripley, a man known for his complex and often contradictory roles in both the US and Confederate armies. The book traces Ripley's journey from his Ohio roots and his service in the Mexican War alongside Ulysses S. Grant, to his controversial career as a Confederate general. It explores his post-war activities in Great Britain, where he engaged in entrepreneurial ventures and engineering projects. Ripley's transformation from a Unionist to a Secessionist, partly influenced by his marriage to a Charleston native, is a critical focus of the narrative. Bennett endeavors to present a balanced portrayal of Ripley, challenging the predominantly negative historical assessments by delving deep into his two-decade-long, postwar life in England.

Main Themes and Topics

The book primarily explores themes of loyalty, transformation, and contradiction. Ripley's life is depicted as a study in contrasts, as demonstrated by his transition from serving the US Army to becoming a celebrated yet contentious Confederate general. The theme of postwar reinvention is also prominent, as Ripley adapts to his new life in London while clinging to elements of his Southern identity. Bennett highlights the historiographical challenges posed by Ripley's life, focusing on why previous historians may have refrained from writing about him. The book emphasizes the importance of re-evaluating historical figures who have been largely defined by negative critiques, thus encouraging a more nuanced understanding.

Writing Style and Tone

Bennett's writing is characterized by meticulous research and an engaging narrative style. The tone is scholarly yet accessible, making it suitable for both academic audiences and general readers with an interest in Civil War history. His detailed descriptions and well-structured arguments provide a compelling portrait of Ripley, one that seeks to balance differing perspectives. Bennett's ability to synthesize two decades of research is evident in the depth and clarity with which he presents his subject's multifaceted life.

Awards and Recognition

Resolute Rebel has been praised as a significant contribution to Civil War literature. It has been described as "a vitally useful addition to the Civil War Charleston literature" by Civil War Books and Authors. The book is also noted for its deeply researched and well-argued narrative, bringing Ripley "from the margins of Civil War history," according to A. Wilson Greene, author of Civil War Petersburg: Confederate City in the Crucible of War.

Criticism

While Bennett's work has been widely acclaimed for its research and balanced portrayal, some readers might find the narrative's academic detail overwhelming if they are more interested in a purely narrative biography. The extensive focus on historiographical analysis may not appeal to those seeking a straightforward account of Ripley's life without the dense contextual background. However, these elements are crucial to Bennett's aim of re-assessing Ripley's legacy and challenging previously held assumptions.