Robert E. Lee in War and Peace

Main Themes and Topics

Robert E. Lee in War and Peace by Donald A. Hopkins focuses on the visual legacy of one of America's most iconic historical figures through an extensive collection of photographs. The book encompasses 61 photographs of Robert E. Lee, offering a comprehensive visual narrative that spans his life as a Confederate general and an educator. Dr. Hopkins provides detailed historical context to each image, furnishing a deeper understanding of Lee's life and the era he lived in. The book also provides insights into antique photography, biographical sketches of Lee’s photographers, and touches upon the inaccuracies present in previously published images.

Writing Style and Tone

Donald A. Hopkins's writing is meticulous and deeply informative, reflecting his background as a lifelong student of the Civil War and Southern history. His style is academic yet accessible, striking a balance between scholarly research and engaging storytelling. The tone is one of respect and reverence for historical accuracy, emphasizing the importance of proper attribution and context in historical photography.

Awards and Recognition

The author's previous works, such as The Little Jeff: The Jeff Davis Legion, Cavalry, Army of Northern Virginia, have earned him accolades like the United Daughters of the Confederacy’s Jefferson Davis Historical Gold Medal. While specific awards for Robert E. Lee in War and Peace were not mentioned, the book is a notable contribution to Civil War literature, showcasing Hopkins's dedication to historical research.

Criticism

There is a noticeable absence of discussions around the broader implications of Lee's legacy, focusing instead primarily on his portrayal through photography. Some readers may find the book to be overly technical at times, with extensive details on photographic techniques and attributions.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

Robert E. Lee in War and Peace embarks on a visual journey through the life of Robert E. Lee, compiling every known photograph of him and accompanying each with thorough historical narratives. Dr. Hopkins reveals new information about the origins and identity of the photographers responsible for these historical images. Through this visual biography, readers gain not only an in-depth look at Lee's life but also an appreciation for the art and context of 19th-century photography. The book serves as both a historical document and a tribute to the legacy of this key figure in American history.