Stonewall

Main Themes and Topics

In "Stonewall" by Byron Farwell, the life and legacy of Confederate General Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson are thoroughly explored. The book delves into the contrasting aspects of Jackson's character, portraying him as both a military genius and a deeply flawed individual. Farwell examines Jackson's quirks—his obsession with work, indifference to danger, and constant professional disputes. The book also unpacks Jackson’s mysterious nature and personality, highlighting his idiosyncrasies, such as sleeping unpredictably during critical moments and his challenges in communication with subordinates. Farwell confronts the mythologized version of Jackson, offering a dissenting view on how Jackson’s survival might have impacted later Civil War battles like Gettysburg.

Writing Style and Tone

Byron Farwell's writing style in "Stonewall" is both lively and meticulous. His narrative combines engaging storytelling with rigorous research, making complex historical events and figures accessible to the reader. The tone is balanced, aiming to present an honest depiction of Jackson. Farwell does not shy away from highlighting the imperfections and controversies surrounding Jackson, which adds depth to the portrait of this legendary but enigmatic commander. The book's prose maintains a sympathetic tone toward Jackson, inviting readers to understand the complexities of his character and military career.

Awards and Recognition

While the book jacket does not specify the awards won by "Stonewall," Byron Farwell's biography has been noted as the first major work on Stonewall Jackson in over three decades, indicating its significance in Civil War literature. The book's reputation is bolstered by Farwell's careful research and his ability to bring fresh insights into Jackson's life and military accomplishments.

Criticism

"Stonewall" has been both praised and critiqued for its unflinching examination of Jackson's flaws. Some readers may find Farwell’s candid portrayal of Jackson’s personality to contradict the valorized image of the general commonly held in popular culture. Additionally, Farwell's exploration of hypothetical scenarios, such as Jackson's potential impact on the Battle of Gettysburg, can be contentious, as they delve into speculative history. This approach, while thought-provoking, invites debate about its overall contribution to the historiography of the Civil War.

Brief Summary

"Stonewall" by Byron Farwell is a comprehensive biography that paints a vivid picture of Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson, a key figure in the American Civil War. It explores the dualities in Jackson's life: his extraordinary military tactics and his personal eccentricities. Farwell sheds light on Jackson's personal challenges, professional conflicts, and the complex nature of his command during crucial battles. Through detailed research and engaging narrative, the book provides an in-depth analysis of Jackson's contributions to the Confederate war efforts and the factors that shaped his legacy.