Surface and Destroy

Brief Summary

"Surface and Destroy" by Michael Sturma is an in-depth exploration of submarine warfare in the Pacific during World War II, focusing on the unique and terrifying experience of surface gun attacks. The book delves into the intricacies of these confrontations that brought submariners from the silent depths of the ocean to face-to-face encounters with the enemy. Sturma offers a detailed examination of both the strategic and personal elements involved in these battles, providing a comprehensive view of the harsh realities of warfare in this era.

Main Themes and Topics

The book extensively covers the transition from stealthy torpedo attacks to the more direct and personal nature of surface gun battles. In doing so, it touches on themes such as the brutal realities of war, the moral dilemmas faced by submariners, and the psychological effects of direct combat. Sturma also examines the evolution of naval strategies as larger Japanese vessels became scarce, forcing American submarines to target smaller crafts. The exploration of personal morality amidst total warfare provides a rich discussion on how individuals and groups navigate the ethics of combat.

Writing Style and Tone

Michael Sturma employs a scholarly yet accessible writing style that manages to weave detailed historical analysis with the narrative of real combat scenarios. His tone remains respectful and objective, allowing the harrowing experiences of the submariners to convey the gravity of war without sensationalism. Sturma's meticulous research and attention to detail bring authenticity to the historical recounts, making the book a must-read for those interested in military history.

Awards and Recognition

While specific awards for "Surface and Destroy" are not mentioned, Michael Sturma's work is often praised within academic circles for its thorough research and contribution to World War II scholarship. The book has been recognized for offering new insights into an often-overlooked aspect of naval warfare.

Criticism

Some readers might find the focus on detailed military strategies and technical aspects of submarine warfare to be dense and challenging. The book’s level of detail, while enriching for enthusiasts and scholars, may overwhelm casual readers who are not familiar with the intricacies of military history. However, this depth is also one of its strengths for those seeking a comprehensive understanding of the subject.