That’s War: An Authentic Diary

Brief Summary

That’s War: An Authentic Diary by William A. Sirmon offers an engrossing account of the day-to-day experiences of Lt. William Arthur Sirmon during World War I. Spanning from January 1, 1918, to November 12, 1918, this diary provides a detailed look into the life of a regular officer in the 82nd Division, 325th Infantry. Beginning in Ft. Gordon, Georgia, where Sirmon trained soldiers, the narrative leads readers through the rugged landscapes of war-torn France. This work captures Sirmon's journey through one of the most turbulent times in history, offering insights into the life of American doughboys and the challenges they encountered throughout the war.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of That’s War revolves around the authentic wartime experiences of American soldiers during World War I. The diary highlights the dualities faced by soldiers— the camaraderie and struggles of military life, the mundane and the extraordinary events of warfare, and the valor and vulnerability of those who served. Sirmon's narrative delves into the intricacies of training, combat, and survival while also touching on his personal growth and reflections amidst the backdrop of war.

Writing Style and Tone

William A. Sirmon's writing style in That’s War is notably engaging and accessible. The diary format captures the immediacy of his experiences and provides a firsthand, unfiltered perspective of life on the front lines. Despite the serious nature of the subject, Sirmon's tone often exudes warmth and subtle humor, offering a lighter relief to the otherwise somber realities of war. His ability to weave excitement and entertainment with educational insights makes it a captivating read, especially for those interested in historical accounts of World War I.

Awards and Recognition

William A. Sirmon was a highly decorated soldier, known for his service during World War I. On February 16, 1919, he, along with Sergeant Alvin York, received high honors including The Legion of Honor of France, the Distinguished Service Cross, and the Croix de Guerre with Palm by General Pershing. These accolades recognized his contributions and made him an honorary citizen of England and France, underscoring the significance of his service depicted in the diary.

Criticism

While the book is celebrated for its authentic and engaging portrayal of wartime experiences, some readers may find the diary's subjective viewpoint limiting in scope. As a personal account, it primarily reflects Sirmon's individual perspective, which may not fully represent the broader experiences of all soldiers who served during World War I.