Their Maryland

Main Themes and Topics

In "Their Maryland," Alexander B. Rossino offers a critical reevaluation of the 1862 Maryland Campaign during the Civil War, focusing on Robert E. Lee's strategic maneuvers. Unlike traditional narratives that might have been influenced by Lost Cause ideology or incomplete sources, Rossino delves into primary documentation to uncover the realities of the Confederate operation. The book addresses pivotal questions, such as the logistical challenges faced by Lee's army, the internal morale regarding secession sentiment in Maryland, and the controversial issues surrounding Special Orders No. 191. Furthermore, Rossino examines the roles of Maryland civilians and the participation of women during this period, providing a comprehensive understanding of societal dynamics while questioning long-held beliefs that have dominated historical discourse.

Writing Style and Tone

Rossino's writing is both engaging and assertive, inviting readers to question established narratives with clear, compelling arguments supported by meticulous research. His ability to balance detailed historical analysis with an accessible writing style makes the book an appealing read for both scholars and Civil War enthusiasts. Rossino's tone is scholarly yet inviting, motivating readers to reconsider conventional interpretations of the Maryland Campaign.

Awards and Recognition

"Their Maryland" has been noted for being a daringly revisionist contribution to Antietam scholarship, earning praise for its insightful examination of the Confederate operation. Endorsements from noted historians like Brian Matthew Jordan, a Pulitzer Prize finalist, highlight the book's impact in reshaping historical perspectives on a critical Civil War campaign.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

"Their Maryland" reconsiders the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia's foray across the Potomac River in 1862, a crucial but often misunderstood operation. Rossino combines rigorous primary source analysis with insightful commentary, challenging long-held assumptions and offering fresh perspectives on the campaign’s key events. By focusing on overlooked issues and employing a thorough investigative approach, Rossino provides a nuanced portrayal of the Maryland Campaign, engaging readers in a compelling reexamination of historical events.