Triumph Forsaken

Main Themes and Topics

Triumph Forsaken by Mark Moyar delves into the complex historical landscape of the Vietnam War, challenging the established narratives and assumptions that have dominated our understanding for decades. Moyar provides a revisionist perspective, arguing that South Vietnam was a crucial interest of the United States and offers a detailed examination of how various international perceptions and power dynamics influenced the conflict.

A significant portion of the book is dedicated to the analysis of Ngo Dinh Diem's presidency and his subsequent overthrow in 1963. Moyar posits that Diem had achieved substantial military and political successes from 1954 to 1963, which were largely underappreciated by historians. The book further explores how the assassination of Diem crippled these advancements, setting the stage for a prolonged conflict.

The narrative continues to scrutinize President Lyndon Johnson's decision-making process post-Diem, arguing that Johnson had alternative policy options that could have sustained South Vietnamese efforts without the massive influx of U.S. troops. Moyar claims that Johnson's choices were driven by inadequate intelligence and flawed assumptions.

Writing Style and Tone

Mark Moyar adopts a scholarly tone throughout Triumph Forsaken, targeting readers who have an academic or intense interest in history and military strategy. His writing is meticulous, often engaging with detailed analysis backed by extensive evidence. Moyar's approach is comprehensive, weaving together a variety of sources to support his claims, which may appeal particularly to those interested in a deeper dive into the Vietnam War's complexities.

Awards and Recognition

While Triumph Forsaken has been appreciated for its depth of research and the fresh perspective it offers on the Vietnam War, its revisionist stance has sparked significant academic discussion and debate. The book has found a place in several academic settings as a crucial text for understanding alternative viewpoints on this pivotal historical event.

Criticism

The book has not been without its critics. Some historians and readers argue that Moyar's revisionist angle is too sympathetic to figures like Diem and overlooks the complexities of Vietnamese politics and society. Critics also contend that Moyar's reliance on certain sources may lead to a somewhat skewed interpretation of events, potentially minimizing the intricacies and missteps of the U.S. involvement in Vietnam.

Brief Summary

Triumph Forsaken offers a reassessment of the Vietnam War, challenging traditional perceptions and emphasizing South Vietnam's strategic importance to U.S. interests. Mark Moyar brings to light new evidence and insights, particularly focusing on the period leading up to and following the assassination of Ngo Dinh Diem. The book contends that different policy choices by U.S. leaders could have resulted in significantly different outcomes for Vietnam, challenging readers to reconsider the established accounts of this troubled period in history.