Fighting for MacArthur

Brief Summary

"Fighting for MacArthur" by John Gordon offers a comprehensive account of the 1941-42 Philippine campaign, focusing on the contributions and experiences of the Navy and Marine Corps. This meticulously researched book brings to light their struggle to support the U.S. Army during a time of dire circumstances in the Pacific War. Gordon utilizes sources from both the U.S. and Japan, official records, and personal diaries to provide an in-depth examination of this critical period.

Main Themes and Topics

The book explores several major themes, including the strategic importance of the Philippines in the Pacific War and the challenges faced by the U.S. military forces as they attempted to hold the islands against overwhelming odds. A significant focus is placed on the Navy and Marine Corps, highlighting how their often-overlooked roles in the campaign were crucial yet fraught with difficulty. Gordon details the unusual missions these branches undertook, illustrating their adaptability and resilience. Another critical topic is the strained relationship between the Navy and General Douglas MacArthur, shedding light on the inter-service dynamics that influenced the conduct and outcome of the campaign.

Writing Style and Tone

John Gordon's writing style is engaging and accessible, making complex military history approachable for both casual readers and scholars. His narrative is both detailed and vivid, allowing readers to gain a clear understanding of the strategic, operational, and human elements of the campaign. The tone of the book reflects a balanced view, providing both admiration for the courage displayed by the military personnel and a critical eye on the challenges and mistakes made during the campaign.

Awards and Recognition

"Fighting for MacArthur" has been praised for its thorough research and contribution to World War II scholarship. It is recognized by the Michigan War Studies Review as a valuable addition to literature on the Pacific War. The book's meticulous use of archives and veteran interviews has been particularly noted as enhancing its depth and authenticity.

Criticism

While "Fighting for MacArthur" has been lauded for its research and narrative style, some readers might find its focus on military operations too detailed and technical at times. The heavy emphasis on military strategy and tactics, while informative, might not appeal to those looking for lighter historical narratives or personal stories of the individuals involved. Additionally, the book may assume a level of prior knowledge about World War II, which could be challenging for those new to the subject.