This Is Really War

Brief Summary

This Is Really War by Emilie Le Beau Lucchesi delves into the poignant and heroic story of Dorothy Still, a US Navy nurse, and her colleagues who served at a military hospital in the Philippines during World War II. Captured by the Japanese forces, these courageous nurses continued to care for fellow prisoners under the direst conditions, showcasing resilience, compassion, and determination amidst the brutality of war. The narrative provides a deep insight into the untold stories of these remarkable women and their unwavering dedication to their duty despite the adversities they faced.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of This Is Really War is the resilience of the human spirit. The book focuses on how nurse Dorothy Still and her colleagues persevered through the harrowing circumstances of war captivity. The theme of duty over self-interest is repeatedly emphasized, reflecting the nurses' commitment to providing care under extreme pressure and danger. Additionally, the book explores themes of camaraderie and solidarity among the nurses, highlighting the strength drawn from human connections in the face of adversity.

Writing Style and Tone

Emilie Le Beau Lucchesi employs a compelling and emotive writing style in This Is Really War. The narrative is meticulously researched, conveying historical accuracy while maintaining a personal and engaging tone. Lucchesi captures the tension and urgency of wartime with vivid descriptions, creating an immersive reading experience. Her empathetic portrayal of the characters allows readers to connect deeply with their experiences, making the historical context both accessible and poignant.

Criticism

While This Is Really War has been praised for its in-depth research and engaging narrative, some readers might feel that the book could benefit from a broader perspective on the geopolitical implications of the events described. The focus on personal stories, while powerful, might overshadow the larger historical framework for those seeking a comprehensive analysis of World War II's Pacific Theater. Additionally, the book's emotional depth and detail-oriented approach may not appeal to readers who prefer a more straightforward historical account.