A New Force at Sea

Brief Summary

A New Force at Sea by David A. Smith narrates the life and career of George Dewey, a pivotal figure in American naval history. The book chronicles his journey from his early days at the U.S. Naval Academy to his rise as the "Admiral of the Navy." It delves into his significant role in the Civil War, his strategic foresight, and his legendary victory at the Battle of Manila Bay during the Spanish-American War. Dewey's celebrity status post-war, his involvement in shaping American naval power, and his complicated legacy are examined in detail. His life encapsulates the transition of the U.S. Navy from post-Civil War stagnation to a formidable global force.

Main Themes and Topics

The book explores several core themes, including leadership, strategy, and celebrity in military history. Smith highlights Dewey's evolution as a naval strategist who foresaw the need for a robust American global presence. It also examines how Dewey's victory at Manila Bay influenced U.S. expansionism and imperialism, setting a precedent for future military endeavors. Furthermore, the book discusses the dichotomy between Dewey's celebrated public image and his personal struggles with the responsibilities and expectations that accompanied his fame.

Writing Style and Tone

David A. Smith employs a detailed and engaging narrative style, bringing historical events to life with vivid descriptions and well-researched insights. The tone is informative yet accessible, allowing readers to appreciate the complex dynamics of Dewey's career and the broader naval history of his era. Smith's writing successfully balances the technical aspects of naval warfare with personal anecdotes that humanize Dewey, making the book appealing to both history buffs and general readers alike.

Criticism

While A New Force at Sea is widely appreciated for its comprehensive scholarship and storytelling, some critics have noted that the book occasionally glosses over certain controversial aspects of Dewey's life, such as his involvement in the Philippine Insurrection. Additionally, some readers might find the extensive focus on naval specifics slightly overwhelming, though this level of detail will likely satisfy those with a deep interest in military history.