For Both Cross and Flag

Main Themes and Topics

In "For Both Cross and Flag," William Issel dives deep into the tumultuous relationship between religion, politics, and civil rights against the backdrop of World War II. The book intricately explores the case of Sylvester Andriano, an Italian American Catholic who faces grave civil rights abuses due to false accusations of harboring Fascist sympathies. The narrative unfolds the tension between religious activism and political rivalries, especially during times of national security crises. At its core, the story uncovers the dangerous intersection of faith-based political activism and urban political dynamics, where personal vendettas and religious biases can disastrously infringe upon individual rights.

Issel uses the real-life account of how political enemies and wartime hysteria can culminate in wrongful persecution, exemplifying broader themes of religious intolerance, ideological conflict, and the perils of government overreach. Furthermore, the book raises pertinent discussions on historical and contemporary issues, such as urban politics and the impact of ethnic and religious identities during periods of heightened national security.

Writing Style and Tone

William Issel employs a detailed, narrative-driven style infused with a scholarly tone, meticulously presenting historical events with precision. He constructs a gripping narrative by combining thorough historical research with compelling storytelling. Issel manages to weave the complex strands of political, religious, and personal elements into a coherent and engaging account. His tone, while primarily academic, remains accessible to the general reader, ensuring that the intricacies of Andriano's case and the broader political climate are comprehensible and thought-provoking.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

The book documents the compelling saga of Sylvester Andriano, an Italian American Catholic leader in San Francisco, who becomes a victim of political maneuvering and anti-Catholic sentiment during WWII. Accused without evidence of Fascist sympathies, Andriano's story is one of injustice marked by his clash with state and federal entities. Through confidential informants and political rivals, his ordeal becomes a cautionary tale of civil rights violations during times of war where democracy is at stake. Issel meticulously presents the figures and forces at play, offering keen insights into the intersection of faith and politics that continue to resonate today.