General James Longstreet

Main Themes and Topics

General James Longstreet by Jeffry D. Wert provides a comprehensive exploration of the life and military career of one of the Confederate Army's most prominent figures. The central theme of the book revolves around Longstreet's role in the Civil War and the subsequent historical analysis that has often placed undue blame on him for the Confederate defeat at Gettysburg. Wert seeks to re-evaluate Longstreet’s contributions and decisions, aiming to highlight his merits as a strategist and leader. The book delves into Longstreet’s relationships with other Confederate leaders, his innovations in military tactics, and the controversial aspects of his military decisions.

Writing Style and Tone

Jeffry D. Wert employs a narrative style that is both engaging and scholarly, offering a detailed account of General Longstreet's career while ensuring that the narrative remains accessible to both history enthusiasts and general readers. Wert's tone is objective, as he meticulously examines historical documents, letters, and records to present a balanced portrait of Longstreet. The author's commitment to historical accuracy is evident, as he aims to cut through years of biased interpretations to present a fair assessment of Longstreet's impact on the Civil War.

Criticism

While General James Longstreet has been praised for its thorough research and compelling narrative, some critics argue that the book leans towards revisionism, potentially overstating Longstreet's strategic contributions to counterbalance former criticisms. A few readers have expressed that although Wert succeeds in portraying Longstreet in a more favorable light, certain aspects of Longstreet's decisions during the war could have been analyzed with more nuance. Nevertheless, the book is widely respected for its attempt to challenge entrenched historical narratives.

Brief Summary

The book offers a detailed account of James Longstreet's military career, with a particular focus on his involvement in the Civil War. Wert provides insights into Longstreet's early life, his rise through the ranks, and his critical role in major battles. The narrative closely examines Longstreet's participation at Gettysburg and seeks to address the longstanding historical debate about his responsibility for the Confederate defeat. By drawing on extensive historical evidence, Wert attempts to vindicate Longstreet and highlight his capabilities as a military strategist. The book not only presents Longstreet's professional life but also sheds light on his personal beliefs, relationships, and his post-war life, providing a well-rounded historical portrait.