Holding Their Breath

Brief Summary

Holding Their Breath by M. Girard Dorsey is a meticulously researched exploration of the diplomatic, legal, military, and social challenges that Western Allies—Great Britain, the United States, and Canada—faced regarding chemical weapons during World War II. The book covers the period beginning with the interwar years and culminating in the defeat of Japan, providing a comprehensive analysis of the complexities involved in confronting the threat and potential use of chemical warfare.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves into several key themes, including the ethical and strategic considerations surrounding chemical warfare during a period marked by technological and military innovation. Dorsey examines the tension between the advancement of chemical weapons and the moral imperatives that guided Allied powers. The analysis is rooted in historical contexts, providing insight into how these nations reconciled their military objectives with international laws and public opinion.

Writing Style and Tone

M. Girard Dorsey utilizes a scholarly yet accessible writing style, making complex historical events comprehensible to both academic and general audiences. The tone is analytical and objective, offering a balanced perspective on the decisions and dilemmas that characterized the Allies' approach to chemical warfare. Dorsey effectively combines narrative storytelling with rigorous academic research, providing a thorough understanding of the subject matter.

Criticism

Critics have noted that while Holding Their Breath offers an in-depth analysis of chemical warfare policies, the book can be dense at times due to the extensive use of technical and diplomatic jargon. Some readers may find certain sections overly detailed, potentially impacting engagement for those less familiar with the historical background. However, the depth of research and the comprehensive coverage of the topic generally outweigh these concerns.