New Approaches to the Military History of the English Civil War

Main Themes and Topics

New Approaches to the Military History of the English Civil War, edited by Ismini Pells, offers a comprehensive examination of various military aspects during the English Civil War and its related conflicts in Ireland and Scotland. The book seeks to bridge the gap between military events and the social, political, and religious developments of the mid-seventeenth century. It begins by re-evaluating key battles, such as Peter Gaunt's study on the Battle of Middlewich, and delves into Thomas Jenkins' exploration of the civilian influence on military outcomes. Furthermore, the contributions consider the roles of ideology and foreign military experience among combatants and conclude by addressing medical treatments and the welfare of soldiers, underscoring the war's human costs.

Writing Style and Tone

The book stands out for its scholarly yet accessible approach. Each chapter is meticulously researched, presenting complex military and historical analyses in a manner that is engaging to both academic audiences and enthusiasts of military history. The tone is informative and analytical, with contributors weaving together facts and interpretations to form a cohesive understanding of the English Civil War from various military perspectives.

Criticism

While New Approaches to the Military History of the English Civil War excels in offering fresh perspectives and researched insights, some readers might find the specificity of certain chapters, such as detailed battle re-evaluations, a bit overwhelming. The book's focus leans heavily towards military aspects, potentially at the expense of a deeper exploration of the interconnected social or political contexts. Regardless, the collection remains an invaluable resource for those with a keen interest in the military dimensions of the era.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

This volume commences with new studies on pivotal battles, like the Battle of Middlewich, which was instrumental in the rise of Sir William Brereton and the establishment of parliamentary dominance in Cheshire. It then transitions to exploring the ideological practices and shared experiences among soldiers. It highlights civilian influence on military outcomes and introduces novel methodologies for analyzing battlefield events. The book further addresses the medical care provided to combatants, depicting the war's harsh realities and ending with an insight into Sir William Waller's defeat at Roundway Down. This variety of topics makes the book a multifaceted analysis of the military history of the English Civil War.