Why Germany Nearly Won

Brief Summary

"Why Germany Nearly Won" by Steven D. Mercatante is a provocative analysis that challenges the prevailing narratives surrounding Germany's defeat in the Second World War. The book delves into the strategic, operational, and tactical aspects of Germany's military engagements, particularly scrutinizing the reasons that made victory seem plausible at certain junctures. Mercatante meticulously argues that the defeat was not a foregone conclusion purely based on the Allied forces' economic or military superiority, presenting a fresh perspective on the complex dynamics of the war.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of "Why Germany Nearly Won" is the reevaluation of military strategies and decision-making processes of the German armed forces. Mercatante explores the potential turning points and pivotal battles where Germany exhibited strategic prowess. In addition, the book analyzes the impact of leadership decisions, technological advancements, and intelligence operations that played critical roles in the progression of the war. By examining these elements, Mercatante presents a nuanced understanding of the operational competencies and missteps that influenced the war's outcome.

Writing Style and Tone

Steven D. Mercatante demonstrates a clear and engaging writing style that maintains a balance between academic rigor and accessibility. His narrative is supported by substantial research, providing readers with in-depth insights while remaining approachable for those without a military history background. The tone is analytical yet impartial, inviting readers to engage with his arguments critically. Mercatante's methodical approach makes the complex subject matter comprehensible, even as he challenges widely held perceptions of the war.

Criticism

While "Why Germany Nearly Won" is praised for its thorough research and fresh perspective, some critics have pointed out that Mercatante's arguments may sometimes overlook the broader context of geopolitical factors and the moral implications of Germany's war aims. Additionally, the book's focus on military aspects might not fully address the consequences of Hitler's strategic blunders and ideology-driven decisions. These criticisms highlight the importance of considering the multifaceted reasons behind Germany's defeat beyond just military engagements.