A Respectable Army

Brief Summary

A Respectable Army by James Kirby Martin offers a comprehensive examination of the Continental Army and its integral role in shaping the United States during the Revolutionary War. This third edition has been thoroughly revised and updated to incorporate the latest historical research and interpretations. The book delves into various facets including military, political, social, and cultural dimensions of the era, providing a rich tapestry of insights into how the army influenced the formation of the new republic.

Main Themes and Topics

The book primarily explores the intricate dynamics between the Continental Army and the development of American identity and governance during the Revolution. It emphasizes the intersection of military history with political and social elements, analyzing how the army not only fought battles but also played a significant role in shaping political ideology and social structures. The authors illuminate the evolution of military strategies, leadership challenges, and the complex interplay between soldiers and civilians in revolutionary society.

Writing Style and Tone

James Kirby Martin and his co-author approach the subject with scholarly rigor, employing a clear and engaging writing style that makes complex historical events accessible. The tone is analytical yet narrative-driven, ensuring that the historical analysis is both informative and compelling. The authors successfully balance detailed academic discourse with narrative elements that capture the broader human experiences of the period, effectively drawing readers into the transformative era of the American Revolution.

Criticism

While A Respectable Army is widely regarded for its thorough research and innovative perspectives, some critics point out that the extensive focus on military aspects might overshadow other revolutionary facets such as economic and diplomatic developments. Additionally, the dense academic tone may present challenges to readers without a strong background in early American history, potentially limiting its accessibility to a broader audience.